Why most creative assets underperform — and how you can fix them

Underwhelming asset performance is often written off as a bad brief, poor targeting, or just 'a mystery.' Yet the reality is that it’s more systemic, and luckily enough—fixable.

Campaign assets that flop aren’t usually due to a lack of talent or budget: It’s because teams are blindsided on what actually works and lack the systems to find out.

• Creative gets approved on gut feel
• Assets go live without being pre-tested
• Then performance data lives in isolated dashboards

But the main problem today is that teams have to move quickly, not smartly. So, why is this? 

‍

1. Creative effectiveness is still a guessing game

Marketers love to talk about data. However, when it comes to creative too much is left to subjectivity. Performance is often judged by channel metrics—instead of creative effectiveness—and by the time the results are in, the budget’s already gone.

This is what you’re losing: 

• A reported $25m worth of brand creative assets never reach the customer. A reminder of how much is wasted when creative decisions aren’t guided by performance data.
• Time and effort: Every unused asset represents creative time, production cost, and strategic thinking that could’ve been repurposed, tested, or optimized.

Without the right systems in place to tag, track and score your assets, you end up repeating mistakes instead of refining your work. To scale what works, you need more than just ideas–you need infrastructure for creative intelligence.

2. Your creative isn’t built to perform 

If you’re not tagging your assets with the right metadata, or any data at all, you’re losing out on insight.

Breaking down your assets at a granular component-level means being able to measure their impact in a media environment (the science behind this is a bit complex—but our team would be happy to explain it to you in a demo). 

This allows you to track performance of specific features, colorways, taglines, brand prominence, emotions, product placement, calls-to-action and a myriad of data points. Put simply, if you’re not tagging your assets properly, it’s near impossible to know which content is driving results and where exactly ad creative fatigue is setting in.

Moreover, the basics are often missed. Marketing week reported that 50% of digital ad spend is invested in ads that fail to hit the mark on a rudimentary level. 

The practical fix? Implementing asset tagging management software that connects your creative output to your media and performance data. This ensures that every asset you produce becomes measurable, and every future decision smarter.

‍

3. Creative ROI is everyone’s problem — and no one’s responsibility

Who’s responsible for tracking creative asset ROI in your organization? The creative team? Performance marketers? Media buyers? 

If you’re not sure, you’re not alone.

Marketers need to build systems that allow you to measure creative ROI and share those learnings across teams. When everyone is aligned on what “great” looks like, you unlock a loop of constant optimization.

‍

4. Underperformance is only spotted after the damage is done

By the time marketers realise an asset isn’t working, the money has already been spent. This underperformance can drag down channel efficiency, inflate CPMs (Cost per Mille), and burn through your audience faster than you can shout “Q4 targets.”

But there’s an upside of getting it right: Kantar reports that media impact is 7x higher when creative is aligned with audience and platform best practices.

Eliminating these assets pre-flight is possible. Software solutions—such as SmartAssets’ analysis tool—flag performance issues, calibrated to your own learnings and against hundreds of platform and industry best practices.

‍

5. You’re not learning fast enough — or not at all

Every campaign generates creative data, but unless you’re capturing those insights and feeding them back into your process, it’s pointless. You’re still stuck in reactive mode.

A survey held by Ziflow says 30% of marketing leaders don’t have a way to see all campaign assets and their status in one place. This significant system gap means that information is siloed and scattered, thereby destroying future creative tracking and past campaign performance visibility.

It’s time to make AI in creative effectiveness your competitive edge. Use performance data to continuously learn which formats, themes, tones, and structures resonate with your audience — and apply those insights to every next iteration.

‍

Want to see how your assets stack up? Book a SmartAssets demo today.

‍